The alkali metal- and ammonia-dependent Birch reduction is the classical synthetic method for achieving dihydro additions to arenes, typically yielding 1,4-cyclodienes. A mild biological alternative to this process are 1,5-dienoyl-coenzyme A (CoA)-forming class I and II benzoyl-CoA reductases (BCRs), widely abundant key enzymes in the biodegradation of aromatic compounds at anoxic environments. To obtain a comprehensive mechanistic understanding of class I BCR catalysis, we produced the active site subunits from a denitrifying bacterium and determined the X-ray structure of its substrate and product complexes at 1.4 Å revealing non-canonical double-cubane [8Fe-9S] and active site aqua-[4Fe-4S] clusters.  Together with kinetic, spectroscopic and QM/MM studies, we provide evidence for a radical mechanism with a [4Fe-4S] cluster-bound water molecule acting as hydrogen atom and electron donor at potentials beyond the biological redox window. .